I know there are still so many bikers out there who still believe the mudguards are ugly and unnecessary. Get all wet and dirty is part of the game, so they say but it is not always the case for all bikers. Some people just like to cruise around town or bike to and from work. If you are one of them you would not want to end up looking sloppy, drenched with water and mud. Getting a mudguard or what they would commonly call bike fenders is the next most logical thing to do. If you are looking for new fenders or a replacement of an old one, finding the right fender can be quite challenging. Our buyer’s guide will help you decide quickly. Given that we have our own criteria for evaluating the items, you are sure to get the best option in the market today.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 4 hrs of research
It looks very sleek and it has a mudflap that adds more functionality.
It has a unique mounting system.
It has a safety release to keep the tires turning even with debris between the fender and the tire.
- Portland Design Works
- Electra Essential Cruiser
- Velo Orange Hammered
- SKS RaceBlade Pro XL
- Zefal Swan
- Crud Cycling Urban Racepack
- Yopoon Fender
- Ass Saver Rain
- Topeak Defender M1
- SKS Bluemels Stingray
- Criteria Used for Evaluation
- Other Factors to Consider
- Frequently Asked Questions
1. Portland Design Works
It looks very sleek and it has a mudflap that adds more functionality.
It has a unique mounting system.
It has a safety release to keep the tires turning even with debris between the fender and the tire.
The front fender can be improved.
This product is made of the highest quality material used for fenders. It is made of polycarbonate and provides the best protection from spray. It keeps you protected from head to toe.Read more
This item has pre-installed stays and brackets so you can easily mount it. It is made to adjust to your bike so you can quickly install it without having to make any modification.
It is made of high-quality polycarbonate and because it is made to last, the manufacturer offers a lifetime PDWarranty.
It is made to fit 700x35 tires max. The pre-installed stays and brackets ensure that the fender fits perfectly to your bike.
The design provides full coverage and shield. It effectively keeps the mud and water sprays away from the rider.
It offers protection from sprays due to the wide coverage of the fender, it protects even your shoes. The riders alongside and behind you will also be protected from sprays due to its rubber mudflaps.
This item is compatible with any road or commuter bikes. There are 2 available sizes so you will not have to worry about getting the wrong size.
2. Electra Essential Cruiser
It has full-length fenders.
It is effective in keeping sprays away from the rider.
It has a very sleek design.
It is not compatible with other types of bike.
This is retro chrome fender that goes very well with Electra Cruiser bikes with tall wheels. It has a very sleek design but very functional too. It provides the best protection.Read more
It is designed for cruiser bikes. It is not as adjustable as you would like them to be but as much as they are made for Ladies Electra Cruiser bike. This item can be adjusted to fit most cruiser bikes effortlessly.
It is very durable with materials made from aluminum alloy making it lightweight yet long-lasting and functional.
It fits any cruiser bike especially models with Flat Foot Technology.
The full-length fender is very effective in keeping mud and water sprays away from the ride as well the other riders with him.
It offers utmost protection from mud and splash. It will protect you from those pesky stripes and keeps your gear looking clean.
This product is ideal for Electra cruiser bikes but it is very compatible with any cruiser bike for that matter. It is compatible with bikes with tires as wide as 2.125”.
3. Velo Orange Hammered
It has a beautiful hammered design.
It is very lightweight.
It is sold in pairs.
This item might have issues if you have tight tire-chain clearance.
This product features the beauty and durability of classic hammered aluminum bike fenders that looks really attractive. It is, however, priced like fenders made of plastic so it is easy on your budget.Read more
This product includes a hardware kit so you can work with most types of mounting job. It may not be as easy to install but very much worth the trouble.
It is made of aluminum alloy to provide strength and durability. It is lightweight so it will not affect your speed or performance.
This item comes with different sizes that riders can choose from. You can be assured of the fit.
The full-length fender and the aluminum material comes together to be effectively functional.
The design perfectly provides protection from mud and water splashes that ruins your clothing and appearance.
This product is compatible with any bike with 700c wheel size and tire width of 35. Best suited for road and commuter bikes.
4. SKS RaceBlade Pro XL
It has a quick release fitting system.
It has a long mud-flap for added protection.
It is compatible with disc brakes.
There are some issues on the adjustments.
This is easy to install clip-on mudguard that is both stylish and functional. This item is sold in pairs and with a paintwork protection film.Read more
It has a double-hinged quick fitting system. You can also adjust the stays to adapt to the radius of the wheel. You can use quick release straps or zip ties to keep it in place.
It is made of superlight flaps that stays in place to provide pure function and durability. It has a paintwork protection film to keep it in tip-top shape.
It fits aero forks and has a smart quick release system that is also double-hinged. It is can be fitted with quick release straps or zip ties.
It is very effective in keeping away water and mud spray because of its extra-long mud flaps.
The superlight clip-on fender offers great protection for your feet and bottom. It also protects the riders behinds you from getting splattered in water and grime.
This product is compatible with 700c tires with a width of up to 32mm. It can adapt to the wheel’s radius by adjusting the stays’ length. It is compatible with bikes that have disc brakes, axles or direct mount brakes.
5. Zefal Swan
It has a quick release mount.
It is compact and lightweight.
It provides protection from road spray.
It is only for rear protection.
This is a very convenient fender to have. It is very flexible and you can easily remove or mount it whenever you want.Read more
This item has an easy to mount and dismount bracket that you can attach to the seat post. It is a quick release so you will not have a hard time using it whenever you need it.
It is made of technopolymer that makes it durable and sturdy to protect you and your bike from mud and rain.
It fits most 700c tire and 28-inch-wide wheels. It fits any hybrid and city bikes.
If you need an effective deflector of rain and mud sprays, you can get it anytime with these detachable fenders.
This clip-on fender offers great rear protection. You and your fellow riders will definitely appreciate this to provide complete protection from sprays.
This product is compatible with any hybrid and city bikes. It can be easily mounted on the seat post so it will not get in the way with any modifications you might have on your bike. And since it is easily detachable with its quick release mounting, it will definitely blend in with your bike set-up.
6. Crud Cycling Urban Racepack
It is lightweight and slim.
It is great for hybrid and mountain bikes.
The race guard is easy to mount.
The length might be an issue for some riders.
This product is lighter and slimmer but offers amazing protection for hybrid trekking bikes and also compatible for mountain bikes. This can be fitted in under one minute with only a 5mm alley without having to take the seatpost out.Read more
You can mount this fender very easily and you do not even have to remove the seat post. It has a flexible tail with a soft nose so you can permanently fix it easily.
It is very durable and it stays in place once fitted. You can be assured that it stays in place. Although this will not last a lifetime, it will last you several seasons that will give you a run for your money.
It is very convenient and easy to fit into your bike. You can get the job done in a minute or two. It is slim and light so it easily fits into your tires.
It is very effective in providing protection from road and trail dirt.
The light and slim fender offer ultimate road protection from dirt and mud.
This very light and slim fender are very compatible with hybrid/trekking and mountain bikes. You can attach it using 3 shims and 2 O-rings.
7. Yopoon Fender
This item is uniquely designed to be stylish and functional.
It has a wide application to handle any weather.
It has a variety of colors to choose from.
The zip ties that come with the fender is a little too thin and brittle.
This product is a lightweight bike fender designed for mountain bikes. It offers excellent protection and comes in a variety of colors that would suit your bike. It also has a very unique design.Read more
It has a very unique folding design to offer added protection from debris flying by when you are riding. It is easy to install and has a quick release function.
It is designed to offer added protection and made to handle any weather. It is durable, sturdy and very lightweight, it won’t get in the way with your performance.
The size of this product is very convenient to mount and will perfectly fit any mountain bike design. It even has a variety of color options so you can fit it perfectly.
This product has an improved folding design that effectively shields you from flying debris.
This product has a unique design that protects your eyes and face from mud and water spray while riding.
The product is compatible with any mountain bikes and rough road trails. It is made easy to mount on rigid fork crowns or arches that are lower in stance. It is easy to install with a quick release function.
8. Ass Saver Rain
This product comes in a variety of colors.
It easy to attach to the saddle rail, anyone can do it.
It is super lightweight, you can easily stow it on your backpack.
There are issues with functionality.
This type of fender is very ideal for people who are not a fan of using fenders but understands the need for it. You can use these fenders conveniently when the need arises and take it off again as soon as you want to.Read more
The best thing about these bike rain fenders is that you can quickly mount it when needed. It is adjustability at its best. All you have to do is fold the tip of the fender and will lock itself securely around the saddle rail. Some people just don’t want fenders on their bike but needs to protect themselves during a surprise rain. Adjust your bike set up easily with these rain fenders.
This item is very durable and once mounted will definitely stay in place. This 4th generation offers added stability and improved mechanism.
This item will fit any standard rail saddle as well as those with carbon rails. It fits 23 to 23 mm wide tires.
These very attractive and lightweight rain fenders are very effective in keeping your bottom dry. Place this on your saddle rails and you will keep your butt dry all the way through by keeping the sprays away from your seat.
The Generation 4 is equipped with Flip-Tip technology to offer secure and utmost protection from rain. It doesn’t matter whether you commute to work or participating in a race, this rain fender is the best protection for you.
It is compatible with most road or commuter bike. You can easily attach it to your saddle rail when it is necessary. It is compatible with any standard rail saddle.
9. Topeak Defender M1
The rear fender allows you to adjust your angle in multiple ways.
It is lightweight.
It has a quick release function.
There are some issues with rear fender installation.
This product offers a compact fender with quick release functions to allow you to install and remove this item in seconds. This product come in pairs and it has guards against grime build up and it makes cleaning a lot easier.Read more
This product can be angled to make it more useful and maximize the coverage. It has a quick release system to quickly install and remove it. The quick release system provides seamless integration with almost all forks.
This product is made of a lightweight and stiff frame that is co-molded using a flexible perimeter substance to provide better coverage. It is very durable with a polished underside for added protection from grime and mud build-up.
It easily fits a seat post that ranges from 25.4 to 34.9mm. The front fender has a QR fork attachment that fits forks with 19.6 to 26 mm and 27.7 to 35mm head tube.
It is lightweight but stiff to offer better coverage. The quality fenders both have polished underside to effectively guard mud build up. This also makes cleaning so much easier.
The M1 front fender and XC11 rear fender provides the protection that you need to enjoy your ride despite the weather and the elements.
This product is compatible with mountain bikes but can fit road and commuter bikes as well.
10. SKS Bluemels Stingray
This product is available in different colors.
It is quick to install.
There are issues about installing it on their bikes but not a real deal breaker.
This product is a set of front and rear guards that come in cool matte black color. This item comes in other modern designs in matt finish for a more stylish look.Read more
This product comes with a new mounting fixed end caps. It is easy to install and comes with different colors to easily match your bike.
This product is made of first-grade plastic and aluminum core to provide high impact resistance. It is made to last and resist the elements with its matt finish.
This item is 680 mm in length for the front fender and 1185 mm for the rear fender. It fits wheel sizes of 700 x 28-38 mm. The width of the fender itself is 45mm.
The full-length fender effectively shields the rider from water and mud spray whilst riding in the city or dirt roads under different weather conditions.
This front and rear fender provide protection for the rider. This keeps them from getting wet and splashed.
This item is compatible with almost all types of bike used for trekking, commuting, fitness training or leisure ride. The stylish design and variety of colors available make it easy for you to match it with your bike.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
There are so many kinds of bikes out there and fenders are designed for these specific bikes.
However, it is still important that the product you choose is adjustable so you can fit it in easily. There are bikers who like to add improvements or customize their bikes. Sometimes standard parts either won’t look good or just won’t fit anymore given the modification. There are also bikes that are used for different purposes and so it has to be adjusted from time to time. A good fender should be able to provide the protection it is designed for even with some modifications.
When you buy stuff naturally you would want to get your money’s worth.
It should not only fit your bike and look good. It should also be able to work hard as you. Once it is mounted it should be able to outlast the harsh elements and the rough terrain. It is important that the product not just serve its purpose, it should also be durable. Most times durability is determined by materials used to make the item. So, these two factors go hand in hand. Don’t be fooled by appearances. There are so many attractive looking fenders out there but they would lack in functionality and durability.
You need to look closely at how the item fits your bike.
Factors that affect the fit are the clearance from the suspension, length of the fender, the mounts or clips you attach it to. You do not want to become a moving rattle while riding or end up with losing fenders.
Of course, all these manufacturers promise the same thing, this is where we come in.
We will do the testing for you so you can narrow your list of choices. One product will always be a cut above the rest and this is what our testers have done. We checked how the length, the position, and the materials all go together to provide the protection it promises among other factors that make a really effective mudguard.
The main and sole function of fenders is protection for you and for other bikers and bystanders.
We tested different types and brands to see which one provides the best protection. The fender should be able to keep the water and grime away from the rider. Riding in the rain or under tougher conditions can become very challenging. Pedaling with wet feet can become doubly hard not to mention it is bad for your health. When the fender does not provide enough protection from the elements it could also be bad for your image. Wearing drenched and mud-soaked clothes is not always a welcome sight.
The fenders unless custom-made should be compatible with your specific type of bike.
This is why we had to check different types of guards because there are so many variations of bikes. Some manufacturers would say it is compatible with road bikes in general or with all mountain bikes. Only to find out that it is not entirely true. The compatibility also affects the effectiveness and the kind of protection it provides. Hence, we feel that this is the most important criteria to consider.
Expert Interviews & Opinions
Make sure that you regularly check and lubricate the drivetrain of your bike to keep it performing at its peak. Regular lubrication can save you a lot of time and money not to mention a headache. When mud, grime, and rust come together, it will wear your drivetrain faster and it can even lead to other damage to your bike.
Before you ride your bike, make sure to check your bolts and nuts. Often times these guys become lose from everyday use and you might end up losing them. This can again add to your cost of maintenance which you could have easily avoided. You can check them regularly and tighten them from time to time. You should be careful to tighten them just right. Overdoing it can also damage the bolts and nuts. You also must check on the tools you use for adjusting them. Some tools are not specifically made for certain types of bolts and nuts, so you make sure you have the right tools.
Each time you ride your bike they’re there to protect you. Regularly cleaning them will not take up a lot of time. It will also help you save by keeping it on top shape. If you let mud and grime settle on your fenders, chances are it will eventually eat it up and rot your fenders. A regular wash or shower, as well as a few scrubs here and there, will keep your fenders performing well for a long time.
Other Factors to Consider
Apart from the 6 important criteria we have listed as our basis for evaluation, we also considered other factors. It is always better and safe to have a backup and the same goes true for evaluating products. There are some products who don’t always have all the criteria we have listed.
These products are all mounted or attached to the bike and we had to check which ones offer the most stability. If the item is not well fitted or irregularly placed, it will not only make an irritating sound it can even hamper your performance or ride.
Materials affect performance, effectiveness, and durability. We checked and researched the materials used by our manufacturers to make sure they are of top quality. The materials also dictate the price. To check whether it is priced fairly, the materials had to be considered in this review.
A lot of people would not think of this as an important feature but size should not be overlooked. Firstly, it affects the fit and the amount of protection it can offer. When buying a fender, you need to check on the size because it should match your bikes needs not to mention the rider’s needs. Second, it is also important because size is also considered when making a shipment.
If you own a bike and have decided to get a mudguard, because you are now enlightened, we want to help you understand other important things to consider before getting one. There are 3 different types in the market and your choice will have to be based on this, primarily.
These items are commonly used by touring bikes. They offer the best coverage because they cover the full length, as the name would suggest. You are completely protected from water and dirt. This also provides more protection for you and your companions, if you are riding with a group or just bystanders. They are popularly known as traditional guards because they have been widely used for the longest time. It is often a permanent fixture on touring bikes, so it is not as if you have an option if you have a touring bike. Chances are, as soon as you buy them, they already have one installed. You might want to just upgrade it to your liking.
Not all full-length guards are the same in size, some are longer and still have larger rubber flap at the end of the mudguard. This extra protection help keeps you from getting wet. The front wheel happens to spray a lot of water or worse, mud. With a longer mudguard at the back, you can protect yourself and the people following you. One of the most important benefits of having a full-length mudguard is that it keeps water away from the brake caliper and the front mech. These parts of your bicycle could do a lot without getting wet or soaked. It also helps keep your saddle bag or rear light dry and protected.
This type of guard is ideal for hybrid or road bikes without built-in eyelets for mudguards. It is easy to strap around the fork leg and rear to provide protection against water. But the amount of protection still depends on how long the fender is. With a clip-on guard, you can easily adjust the height and keep it in place until you have no need for it. Therefore, it is preferred by some people, because it is detachable you can choose to clip it on only when it is needed. Some people are still adverse with fenders and unless it is entirely necessary, they would rather not put it on. Some bikes are designed without ready mounts, so they would naturally have to go for clip on.
Mountain Bike Mudguards
The biggest problem yet the most common issue with hitting the trails is grime. When it is wet and muddy, staying dry and keeping your vision clear if very important. Most mountain bike fenders are usually heavy duty because of the challenging terrains. A recent popular option for mountain bikes are minimalist front fenders that are positioned either on the down-tube or under the crown. It keeps your suspension free of any obstruction. There are other kinds of mountain bike fenders to suit other biker’s preferences and needs. There are fenders mounted on the seat post or better protection against dirt coming from the backside. It provides clearance from suspension and ideal for larger tires.
Now you have an idea what the types of fenders or guards, you will somehow understand why it is important. Not all types of guards will fit your bike. A stock design would have the basic requirements or would come with guards already in place. But as most bikers end up doing, sooner or later you’d start customizing your bike to look better and perform better.
If you are a biker, the word mudguard or fender should not be that hard to explain. Many bikers still cling to the idea that these are unnecessary, but if you bike through autumn and winter you would know better. Biking through muddy terrain or even just a drizzle will not only get you all soaked but also have you looking like a mess. Some riders would argue that it is all part of the sport but then again if you are riding in the city, you’ll have to think twice. Most especially for people who bike their way to work, you want to get there in one shape and looking presentable still. Without these guards, you are sure to catch all the water thrown from the wheel. Not to mention getting a straight line of dirt or mud on your back shirt or jacket. And I just have to make mention that, getting rid of these stains will really test your patience and skills.
We rounded up so many bike fenders and tested each item on several bikes and different trails. We would like to give you our best picks for the best fenders. Of course, we didn’t just attach the fenders to the bike and went riding. We had to set criteria to narrow down our list and so we can provide you with the best options.
Frequently Asked Questions
If you have a hard trail fender, you are likely to get splashed every time. What you can probably do is adjust the angle of the fender and attach it closer to your tires. Often the angle of the fender affects the splatter. My guess is that your fender is too short to provide full protection. If after you have experimented adjusting the angle but still get the same result, you may have to consider getting a new one. Just make sure that you get it fitted first.
It is funny how some people can make light of this by saying, avoid the bumps. Humor aside, it is really irritating. What you can probably do at the moment is to make sure all the bolts and nuts are tightly secured. Sometimes if the bolts that you are using are incompatible with the fender, you will end up with loose bolts and nuts, hence the rattling sound. You can also observe where the rattling is coming from. There could be other issues as well so it is better to inspect and address it. If you can’t fix it, I suggest you have it checked by a professional, they usually know how to fix these things.
Actually, choosing the best fender for your bike is not as simple as buying your bike. When you choose a fender, you must make sure it fits your bike. Certain fenders are made for specific types of bike. Know your bike type and then move on choosing your fender. The best fenders regardless of the type of fender is the one that provides the best protection against mud, water, and grime. There are different lengths that fenders offer different protection. Be sure to scrutinize your choice of bike fenders and don’t just go for the looks.
Disc brakes on bikes are not a problem. I have a Trek DS4 when I mounted my fender, I had no problem with it. If you check carefully, you will notice that there is provision for mounting fenders on your bike. If it is there, I do not think you will have any problems mounting your fender. If you are still unsure, I would suggest you ask to have it installed as soon as you get it. They will know what to do.
Both are actually good choices. Each has its own benefits so it should just depend on your choice. Both are lightweight and provides good protection from water and mud. Plastic fenders also come in very attractive colors so you can really add flair to your bike. However, plastic fenders will last only for a limited number of seasons, 3 at the most. While aluminum would last for a longer period.