to top 10 table

Best Fireplace Screens

last updated Feb 12, 2019

If you have a fireplace built into your home, then you probably will need a screen. What is nice is there are screens out there that are specially designed for this purpose. For the most part, the purpose of their design is to help shield those present from the radiating heat being emitted from the fireplace. However, they can also be an ideal way to block any flying embers from landing into your living room. Of course, with children running around, they can also act as a safety precaution. No matter how you slice it, they serve their purpose. Yet, buying one is a different animal and that is why you have stumbled across this guide today.

This is the best product on our list that is currently in stock:

icon
Panacea Products
93/100 our score
Materials
93
Style
92
Durability
93
Size
94
Panacea Products
Why is it better?

Equipped with hinged doors

Designed with steel mesh

The stability issues can be tweaked

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Panacea Products
Test Winner: Panacea Products
Researched Sources
15
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1.1k
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
12
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
15
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Jordan Coleiro:

This buying guide for fireplace screens has been put together to show you the best researched and reviewed screens to give you the extra sense of protection and style for your fireplace. A great fireplace screen to keep your eye on is the Deco Metal. We love this fireplace screen because it is known for being decorative, easy of use, and is built to last.

Sorting Options
Materials Style Durability Size By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.5
Materials
95%
Style
95%
Durability
94%
Size
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$92.71
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Materials
93%
Style
92%
Durability
93%
Size
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$36.04
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Materials
94%
Style
93%
Durability
91%
Size
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$247.95
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Materials
89%
Style
91%
Durability
91%
Size
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$149.95
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.5
Materials
90%
Style
90%
Durability
88%
Size
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$70.31
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Materials
88%
Style
90%
Durability
88%
Size
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$135.95
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Materials
87%
Style
87%
Durability
87%
Size
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$84.68
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.5
Materials
88%
Style
87%
Durability
86%
Size
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$55.99
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.3
Materials
87%
Style
87%
Durability
87%
Size
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$42.70
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86
Materials
85%
Style
85%
Durability
86%
Size
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.03.19)
$89.74
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Deco Metal
  • Panacea Products
  • Plow & Hearth Alternating Panels
  • Plow & Hearth Small Crest
  • Verdugo Woodland Wonder
  • Metal Decorative Mesh
  • Adalia Wrought Iron
  • Large Floral
  • Pleasant Hearth Arched
  • Uniflame Sparkguard
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

Top Ten Fireplace Screens

1. Deco Metal

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.5
Deco Metal
Materials
95
Style
95
Durability
94
Size
94
best offer for today
$92.71
Pros:

Both decorative and functional

The hinges allow the gate to fully open

The scroll work is made of solid metal

Cons:

Color could be different when received

The artisanship on display here is something to behold. However, Deco also designed their model to be highly-functional with solid metal and integrated mesh for protection.

Read more

Main Materials
If it is not broke, then why fix it? Deco also decided to go with a mesh structure as it has fantastic benefits.

Style
While this does not have any doors, it does have three panels (with two on the side). Due to this, the hinges allow the gate to open fully.

Build Quality
The solid metal construction is more than noticeable but some buyers have noted this does a feel a bit on the cheaper side.

Dimensions
Remember, there are two panels (one on each side) so you can adjust the width a bit (leaving the panels tucked away). As a whole, this measures 52 inches wide by 31 inches tall.

Visual Appeal
Be aware that several consumers warn that the actual product is brighter than the photo indicates (also claiming there is more forest green than it looks). Still, the Fleur De Lis accents offer a sophisticated appeal.

Overall
For this specific model, the pictures seem to be a bit deceiving. If the tint of forest green is appealing to you, then the design as a whole should be, as well.

2. Panacea Products

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Panacea Products
Materials
93
Style
92
Durability
93
Size
94
best offer for today
$36.04
Pros:

Equipped with hinged doors

Designed with steel mesh

The stability issues can be tweaked

Cons:

Extremely light in weight and easily collapsible without modifications

To get the most out of this next model, you may have to make a few modifications. But, they really will be worth it to increase the stability as this triple panel design is fantastic.

Read more

Main Materials
Thanks to the steel mesh screening, any sparks or embers that release from your fire will be guarded against.

Style
A lot of you will love the style of this design. There are three panels in total, with a center panel and two side panels. What is nice about this is the side panels can extend to fit different openings.

Build Quality
While the frame is tubular steel, the stability is very questionable. If you make some modifications, which will require a bit of prior expertise, this can be made to be more stable, though.

Dimensions
As a whole, this measures 48 inches by 30 inches. Now, each side panel measures 12 inches so the size can be customized a bit (in regard to the width, not the height).

Visual Appeal
In terms of appeal, this is a very basic design through and through. Still, the mesh coupled with the black finish is far from unappealing to the eyes.

Overall
It is really hard to beat this price. But, if you are not willing to make slight modifications then this is not the best solution if you have animals or kids running around.

3. Plow & Hearth Alternating Panels

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.8
Plow & Hearth Alternating Panels
Materials
94
Style
93
Durability
91
Size
89
best offer for today
$247.95
Pros:

Will fit flush

The two hinged doors make fire-tending easier

The frame is rigid, lightweight and strong

Cons:

Overall, the hardware could be improved

If you are seeking a bit of style and grace, then this is more up your alley. But, its decorative design sometimes is overshadowed by its alternating panels of glass and mesh screening.

Read more

Main Materials
The design here is quite ingenious. Tempered glass panels are alternated with mesh screening. What this achieves is the luxury of cut glass and the convenience of mesh.

Style
There are two doors in all and each of the doors sports two panels (meaning there are four panels in all). They each have handles and also a magnetic latch to ensure a secure closure.

Build Quality
Not only is the tubular steel frame rigid, strong, and lightweight, it is also coated with a powder finish. However, the glass panels themselves are held together by flimsy tabs.

Dimensions
You have the option of selecting either the small or large model. The former measures 38 inches by 31 inches and the latter measures 44 inches by 33 inches.

Visual Appeal
This could be the most elegant design on this entire list. Not only does the glass and powder-coat finish add to the appeal, but the decorative design will fit most any décor.

Overall
If Plow & Hearth would have engineered this with superior hardware, it would have topped this list as the best model in the world. Still, second is not bad in the slightest.

4. Plow & Hearth Small Crest

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Plow & Hearth Small Crest
Materials
89
Style
91
Durability
91
Size
93
best offer for today
$149.95
Pros:

Features a magnetic secure closure

Will fit flush for maximum protection

Copper and black styles are available

Cons:

Color can be different from the picture

This is the third straight model from Plow & Hearth and it goes without saying that they have stamped their name on this technology. Their Small Crest is a two-door design that is flowing with detail.

Read more

Main Materials
As with most of the options on this list, this is one that is designed of heavy-duty mesh for the main material.

Style
Being a two-door design with integrated handles, this opens much like a gateway would. It provides you full access to maintain your fire while also sitting flush thanks to the flat guard design.

Build Quality
Much like the previous design, this is another one that utilizes tubular steel and a powder-coat finish. Yet, the stands on the end can be a bit unstable.

Dimensions
Plow & Hearth provides their consumers with multiple size options. You can either select a 38-inch by 31-inch model or one that measures 44 inches by 33 inches.

Visual Appeal
The scrollwork needs to be applauded here as it completely elevates this design. For sure, this will add necessary beauty to any décor in any season.

Overall
Another strong showing from Plow & Hearth and while this is their third best effort, it is still better than most designs out there. That is quite impressive ladies and gentlemen.

5. Verdugo Woodland Wonder

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.5
Verdugo Woodland Wonder
Materials
90
Style
90
Durability
88
Size
90
best offer for today
$70.31
Pros:

The silhouette appeal is marvelous

Both doors will swing open

The measurements seem to be very accurate

Cons:

The handles tend to heat up

If you are an individual who enjoys nature and enjoys the vast wonders of the forest, then you will be eating the Woodland Wonder up. Of course, the latches could have been a bit improved.

Read more

Main Materials
There is metal everywhere here and that typically is never a bad thing. The main material for the screening is mesh.

Style
This is comprised of two doors which can be secured at the bottom with a sliding latch. When needed, raise the latch and the doors can swing open.

Build Quality
Despite being mostly high-quality, the latch itself could have been engineered with better quality. Also, the stands are made of thin metal.

Dimensions
As one buyer noted, the provided dimensions are very accurate. What you get here is a unit that measures 38 inches by 31.25 inches.

Visual Appeal
Without question, the design is riveting here. The silhouettes of the evergreens and forest creatures coupled with the outer trim of pine cones make for a stunning visual.

Overall
For grace and style alone, this is a worthy contender. However, some cheap integrations here and there hurt the overall value but the Woodland Wonder is still more than plausible.

6. Metal Decorative Mesh

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Metal Decorative Mesh
Materials
88
Style
90
Durability
88
Size
89
best offer for today
$135.95
Pros:

Baby-Proof

Easy to assemble

One-Year warranty

Cons:

Could be more durable

This fireplace Screen is not only built to last but has a stylish design to bring that extra style to your home fireplace. Another great feature that this fireplace feature brings to the table is the fact that it is baby-proof. This means that you can sleep easy knowing that this screen will offer extra protection which will keep your family safe.

Read more

Materials
Welded to the frame is heavy-duty mesh and this allows the heat to come through while also blocking flying embers from entering into your living room.

Style
This is a two-panel design which adds a little style to your fireplace. It is quite easy to assemble and use, as you lift the center latch to get access to your fireplace.

Durability
Instead of hollow tubes, this frame is crafted of solid steel. Adding onto this is the powder-coat finish which adds enhanced protection and durability to the metal.

Size
Overall, this fireplace screen measures 44 inches in width and 33 inches in height. It will fit most fireplaces and provide complete coverage and protection.

7. Adalia Wrought Iron

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Adalia Wrought Iron
Materials
87
Style
87
Durability
87
Size
90
best offer for today
$84.68
Pros:

Adds a refined look to any home

Built of wrought iron

It is a traditionally inspired design

Cons:

May not completely fit flush

Now, what is interesting about this design is it is traditionally inspired. This means it is merely one giant piece. But, it is glowing with elegance and performs very well.

Read more

Main Materials
There is mesh backing integrated into this model and it is welded on the back. If you did not want the mesh, which would defeat the purpose of the design, you could cut it out, though.

Style
Given that this is a traditional design, there are no doors or extra panels. Instead, to gain access to the fire, you must simply move this out of the way. Also, most users agree that it is hard to get this to rest flush.

Build Quality
Provided the fact that this is designed with wrought iron, it is pretty sturdy. A guessing man would say it weighs around 35 to 50 pounds.

Dimensions
As mentioned, this may not fit flush with your fireplace. Still, for your reference, it does measure 47.75 inches by 35.75 inches.

Visual Appeal
In addition to the natural grace of wrought iron, this has an artistic design and appeal. It is certainly a refined look and will fit in exquisitely with most decors.

Overall
For those seeking a multiple door or panel design, look elsewhere. Yet, if you admire the simple one-panel design and the traditional grace, you could really appreciate this option.

8. Large Floral

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.5
Large Floral
Materials
88
Style
87
Durability
86
Size
89
best offer for today
$55.99
Pros:

Backed by a one-year warranty

Made of wrought iron

Performs very well for protection

Cons:

Some buyers note that it is a bit flimsy

It goes without saying that the wrought iron and powder-coat finish construction of this next model produces a rustic feel while also providing longevity. If it were a bit more structurally sound, though, it could have been even better.

Read more

Main Materials
Due to the fact that the mesh screening from the panels is made from wrought iron, it allows for enhanced spreading of heat and overall protection.

Style
This is another design that comes with three single hinged panels and it does so in an arched design.

Build Quality
As just mentioned, this is an excellent combination of wrought iron with a powder-coated finish. This combination is as stylish as it is durable.

Dimensions
When this bad boy is fully expanded, meaning all the panels are extended, it is going to measure 51 inches in width and also 31 inches in height.

Visual Appeal
In addition to the rustic appeal of the wrought iron, the top border sports a decorative design. All in all, very few consumers will see this as ugly or unattractive.

Overall
Due to the overall flimsiness of this design, it is not an adequate solution for protection from children or animals (as they may knock it down). Still, it is going to last and will provide protection.

9. Pleasant Hearth Arched

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.3
Pleasant Hearth Arched
Materials
87
Style
87
Durability
87
Size
88
best offer for today
$42.70
Pros:

Provides solid protection

The overall gothic design is appealing

It will fold together

Cons:

It is a very light model that can be tipped over

For the price of admission, this is a very competent model here. Plus, the Victorian gothic design is going to add to your existing décor perfectly, for most people that is.

Read more

Main Materials
This is yet another heavy-duty mesh screen and it safely protects you against sparks and ashes emitting from your fire.

Style
Pleasant Hearth went with a three-panel design and it is hard to argue with that. The side panels will extend out if you need them to.

Build Quality
While this has stability issues and can be tipped over, it is comprised 100 percent of steel. Plus, it does sport a powder-coated finish.

Dimensions
When assembled, which is not required as it comes assembled, this measures 48 inches in width by 30 inches in height.

Visual Appeal
There is nothing outlandish about this design but the Victorian gothic appeal and black powder-coated finish combine for a stellar appeal, all things considered.

Overall
You always have to consider good budget options as sometimes, you simply can’t afford the top-of-the-line designs. In this case, that is exactly what you are looking at.

10. Uniflame Sparkguard

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86
Uniflame Sparkguard
Materials
85
Style
85
Durability
86
Size
88
best offer for today
$89.74
Pros:

Features a black finish

It is designed to fit snug and flush

Designed with heavy gauge mesh

Cons:

Could be more durable

Basic does not always have to be a bad thing and in this case of this spark guard, it is not bad at all. Then again, it is a single-panel design which could become a nuisance very quickly.

Read more

Main Materials
While this is made of mesh, one buyer noted that it appeared like some of the wire was not weaved. Since it is black, though, you may not even notice it.

Style
Consider this one big piece altogether. Due to the fact that it is only one panel, you will need to move it to gain access to your fireplace.

Build Quality
Some customers have actually received this with noticeable damage. But, if it comes unscathed, the wrought iron frame and steel legs should be long-lasting.

Dimensions
At only 44 inches in height, this is not quite as tall as some of the other options on this list. Also, the width measures 33 inches.

Visual Appeal
There is no way to sugarcoat the fact that this is not a decorative option. It is plain Jane and for some people’s tastes, this will be exactly what the doctor ordered.

Overall
Some of you will not put up with the inconvenience of not having convenient access to your fire at all times. Then again, for a single panel option, this is pretty solid.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

Probably the first major area of concern for you is the main material. Now, this is referring to the actual paneling itself and not the frame. It is going to come down to either mesh or glass. While you will probably see many guides claim that glass is superior, mesh tends to be the more popular option amongst consumers. The claims that glass is superior are certainly not false or unwarranted as for all intents and purposes, it may just be. They will be capable of withstanding unreal temperatures while also being a joy to look at. But, the thing about glass paneling is it requires a lot of maintenance and mesh does not. Not saying that mesh does not need any maintaining, but the glass is definitely more high-maintenance.

Another really nice aspect of the mesh is that it combines style and durability in its own right. The metal that is typically used for the screens, which can be wrought iron, steel, etc., is both durable and resilient. Some consumers may even prefer the look of mesh over the glass, to be honest.

Style

Now it is time to talk about the style. Fireplace screens come in an array of different styles and all of them have their own distinctions. Probably the simplest of all the styles is the single-panel design. This offers more of a streamlined look and typically is designed with integrated handles to make it easier to lift them. Of course, there are also multiple-panel designs and as it sounds, these sport more than one panel. The benefit of this type is that they can be folded when not in use and offer a 3D look (which is ideal for larger rooms).

However, then there are door screens. With this type of design, you can open the doors up and you then have quick access to your fireplace. Clearly, this is the most convenient of the options as with the other types, you have to physically move the unit to gain access to your fire. If you load your fireplace with wood and maintain it often, you may want to shoot for this type.

Durability

The main material of the paneling has already been documented and discussed but what about the rest of the design? Indeed, the actual screen itself is simply one part of the overall design as you also need to pay attention to the overall build. One benefit of this type of design is you do not need to worry about weathering as these will not be exposed to the elements. But, this does not mean you should settle for a flimsy type of metal, either. Two of the more popular metals that you will see with this technology are wrought iron and steel. Between the two, steel is harder and stronger than iron but wrought iron has a grainy and rustic appeal.

No matter, look for some type of finish (with the best probably being a powder-coating) as this will protect the metal and enhance its durability. Also, and this becomes important if you have children running around, assess the stability. Some units are quite flimsy and if your child runs into them, may get knocked over.

Size

This is where you need to be smart. You will be doing yourself a disservice if you invest in a screen that does not properly fit in front of your fireplace. So, due to this, you need to do some measuring. What you want to do is measure the opening (both in its width and its height). Now, this is where things can get a little cloudy as you would believe that is it. However, nearly all manufacturers and experts will inform you to add to your existing dimensions. This is because you need an adequate amount of coverage and it is always better to have extra space than not enough.

So, it is typically advised to add around 10 to 12 inches to the width and three to five inches to the height. Once you have your number, write it down as you will need to reference that size. Now, also remember that multiple panel models can extend. So, with these, the sizing can be customized a bit. Keep that in mind if you are interested in that specific type.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Size
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
Style
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Look for style and functionality

If you came into this believing that you were foolish for actually wanting a design that you find appealing, understand that you are not foolish at all. When you add any sort of product in your home, the style and appeal will be considered. Whether it is a kitchen appliance or a new piece of furniture, style is as important as function. But, you should never prioritize appeal over function that is for sure.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: How to Clean the Screen?
a:

Remember when it was claimed that glass requires more maintenance than mesh? Well, this is where that comes into play. For mesh, which will not need to be cleaned as often, it is probably best to just take a damp cloth to remove all the soot. But, it may not be that easy with glass as glass shows more than mesh. What you can try, and this is a fairly popular solution, is to clean it with a vinegar solution. What you will need is a solution comprised of three cups of warm water, one tablespoon of ammonia and one cup of vinegar.

Ideally, mix it into a spray bottle and spray the solution on the glass. From there, allow it to sit for around 30 seconds. Then, take a clean cloth and scrub the solution until the soot is loosened. You can repeat this process as many times as needed to get the glass as clean as you desire.

q: Should Glass Doors be Kept Closed?
a:

If you invest in a mesh screen, then this question is not going to concern you. However, if not and you do decide to get a model with glass doors, you need to know that they should be open at certain points. You see, even though certain glass has an insanely high-tolerance to high-temperatures, it can only handle so much. If you have your fire burning at full blaze, then you should probably do so with the doors opened. Not only could it risk the integrity of the glass but also the finish around the glass.

Now, if the fire is not too hot then you could probably get away with leaving them closed. You may end up spending a lot of money on this product so why risk damaging it?

q: Are they even Necessary?
a:

There is probably someone out there, who asked this question right away, admit it. Some consumer products are simply being designed to add luxury and convenience in your life and the question is, are fireplace screens that type of product? The short answer is no, not really. As was mentioned at the beginning of this guide, there are many different reasons why you need to get a screen for your fireplace.

For starters, even controlled fires can be a safety hazard as what happens if an ember or a coal spits out from the fire and lands in your living room? Oh, and how about this one? With children and pets running around your home, do you really want them to even have a chance of accidentally getting too close to the fire? Yes everyone, they really are necessary.

q: How to Remove Rust from Them?
a:

Whenever you buy any product that is made of metal and it features any iron at all, even metals that feature iron as an alloy, you have to worry about rust. Sometimes, it can be tough to prevent it and if you notice that it has begun to form, there is a way you can remove it. What you need to do is to take your screen outside and invest in a metal brush. This is probably the easiest way to remove rust and on the areas that have begun to rust, run the metal brush over them.

Do not be afraid to scrub as you need to get as much powder off as you physically can. If you want to avoid this solution, though, you can try to use a specially formulated cleaner to remove the rust.

q: What is the Difference Between a Spark Guard and a Fireplace Screen?
a:

Something that has not really been discussed yet is what the difference is from a spark guard and this piece of equipment. Well, if you remember, one spark guard actually made an appearance on this list and they are actually pretty much the same type of design. However, they are designed to provide protection all around with single-panel designs fitting snugly. You could almost consider them an enhancement but to be honest, they are pretty much the same thing. In a technical sense, a spark guard could simply be considered a design type.

q: What Exactly Causes Rust?
a:

Okay, even though this does not have a direct tie-in to the buying process at hand here, it is a question that feels appropriate to answer. Even though you now know how to remove rust if it becomes present on the screen that you invest in, ideally, the key is to never allow the rust to form, in the first place. Again, as long as iron is in the fold, rust can occur.

You may not know this but when a metal rusts, it is actually returning to its natural unrefined state. They all start out as rust so it is always there. But, rust is able to occur when three elements combine. Those being any type of water, oxygen and iron. Now, and this is where it gets scientific, when iron and oxygen combine the iron will lose electronics to oxygen atoms. This is known as oxidation and when it occurs, a chemical reaction is produced and this is formally known as Ferric Oxide. Or, you may know it better as rust.

Sources

  1. Melissa Quintero , The 10 Best Fireplace Screens to Buy in 2019, Dec 20, 2018