Best Dog Poop Bags
Besides love, companionship, and great times, dogs also leave you with something else, something to clean up. Yes, we are talking about poop. No one likes the person that doesn’t pick up after their pet while out for a stroll, but who enjoys the idea of carrying a bag of poop?
The good news is that if you invest just a little bit of money in a pack of dog poop bags that are specifically designed to carry your pet’s waste while still being easy on the environment, the chore of picking up after your pet will be a little less gross. Most of these products come with a small dispenser that can be worn on your belt loop or hooked to your leash. If it isn’t included with the purchase of the bags, they are typically sold separately at an affordable price.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 13 hrs of research
Made from recycled materials
Nice lavender scent
- Earth Rated
- Downtown Pet Supply
- Gorilla Supply
- My AlphaPet
- Mighty Paw
- Criteria Used for Evaluation
- Other Factors to Consider
- Frequently Asked Questions
Top 10 Picks
1. Earth Rated
Made from recycled materials
Nice lavender scent
Some feel the plastic dispenser is a little flimsy
Earth Rated is one of the top brands out there on the market and is one of the most trusted by previous users. They make really strong and pleasantly scented products that come with a cute carrying case so that you can keep your hands free to do other things.Read more
There are three different packages that you can choose from. The first option comes with only 15 pouches, the second option comes with 30, and the last option comes with 900. Of course, if you just want to take these for a trial run before stocking up, the 15 count option will be your best bet. Each option comes with a dispenser.
The container that comes with these is small and compact and takes the shape of a giant multivitamin. You can hook it on to your belt or your purse, and pull out a pouch when the time comes. What makes these great is that the back of the container has a little holder where you can hang one of the used pouches so that you don’t have to carry it around for the remainder of your walk. Each pouch measures to be 9 inches wide and 13 inches long.
Earth Rated claims that their products are able to completely decomposed in a landfill in about 24 months. All of their packaging and content products are always made from recycled materials, so you know you are buying a product from a company that cares about the environment.
This is one of the more affordable options out there on the market. If you opt for the small option with 15 pouches, it will cost you less than you spent on a cup of coffee this morning.
This product hits all of the marks that a responsible pet owner would want- it has a nice lavender scent, it fits compact and hands-free, and it is good for the environment. This is hands down our favorite option we found out there on the market, and they have a long line of users that feel the same way.
2. Downtown Pet Supply
Comes in a variety of colors
Easy to separate
Not environmentally friendly
Slightly smaller than the standard size
What we liked most about this product from Downtown Pet Supply was that they came in really fun colors and designs. Of course, the quality was still up to our standards, but the fun colors and designs are what really makes these stand out from the crowd.Read more
Users have the option to select from packages that come with 180 pouches and run all the way up to 2,200 pouches. With whichever amount you choose, a cute dispenser is included. There aren’t really any other brands on the market that offer their product in that quantity- and the price point is still incredibly reasonable.
Like we said earlier, the design is what really makes them stand out from the rest. Users can select from a number of fun, solid colors such as blue, green, pink, and purple, or they can opt to get the rainbow package with all of the colors included. Each pouch is accented with cute white paw prints, and the dispenser that connects to the leash is shaped like a bone.
While the front of the packaging says that they are biodegradable, users have discovered that the materials used to make these pouches will not break down over time. If it is important that your pouches are good for the environment, these aren’t going to be for you.
If you are looking for something that is incredibly affordable and allows you to buy enough pouches that might last for half of the life of your pet- these are going to be an excellent option to take with you on your walks together.
These pouches are fun, colorful, sturdy, and leakproof. They are, however, just slightly smaller than many of the other standard sizes out there on the market so it is important to keep that in mind, especially if you have a larger pet.
3. Gorilla Supply
Good for the environment
Comes with a dispenser that is shaped like a bone
Shorter than the standard design
Some users do not like how see-through they are
For those that are looking for something that is made from high-quality materials, comes in at an affordable price point, and is still good to the environment- this is going to be the product for you. It doesn’t have a lot of design options offered, but it makes up for the basic style with quality and durability.Read more
Unlike many of the other brands, these are only offered in packages of 1,000. One roll holds 50 pouches, and that roll can fit inside the dispenser that is included with purchase.
These pouches are only offered in one solid color- bright blue. The carrying case is solid white and looks like a bone. This dispenser can be easily clipped onto your pet’s leash so that you will never have to worry about leaving them at home and being caught in an uncomfortable situation.
This is where Gorilla Supply really shines. The pouches are considered to be BPA free, and they are made from EPI plastic. EPI plastic is something that you always want to look for in these products. This means that the bags will break down over time if exposed to sunlight and oxygen. The UV rays break down the material over a timeline of about 12-24 months.
The cost of these makes them one of the most affordable on the market, especially considering how many you get with your purchase. If you want something that is good for the environment and your wallet, this will be a welcome addition to your walks.
We should note that some users find that these pouches are a little see through- which can be a little off-putting for some. They are also a little bit shorter, so tying a secure knot can be a little bit more difficult. However, if you want something that is good for the planet and doesn’t cost you that much, this is an excellent option.
Made from EPI plastics
A little pricey
Difficult to open
Roll doesn’t hold that many pouches
Some pet owners find that the most off-putting thing about picking up after their pet is the smell that follows. Carrying around a bag that has a foul odor isn’t going to make the rest of your walk very enjoyable. PetLove works to eliminate that problem, and makes pouches that are thick and durable, and are also heavily scented.Read more
PetLove only sells this product in packages of 240. One rolls contains 16 pouches- which is a little bit smaller than many of the others on the market. You will need to replace the pouches in your dispenser more frequently.
Each pouch is offered in a rich purple design and has a cute drawing of a dog and a cat on the front. What makes these stand out from all of the other brands is that they are offered in two pleasing scents- lavender and baby powder. Included with purchase is also a purple dispenser that is shaped like a bone.
Just like any of these products that are environmentally friendly- this one is made from EPI plastics. What this means is that while this pouch isn’t classified as biodegradable, it will break down over a long enough timeline as long as it is exposed to UV rays as well as oxygen.
If you compare the value of this product to other products that are offered in quantities of 240- this brand is considerably more expensive. However, if you want something that is really going to kick out any bad odors- this will be well worth the slightly padded price tag.
If you are on the hunt for something that is durable, and that comes with a pleasing scent that will mask any foul odors on your walks- this is a great product that is also considered good for the environment.
Leash clip dispenser included
Very durable pouches
Black bags are not environmentally friendly
Some find they are difficult to separate
AmazonBasics makes a product that is a lot similar to the Earth Rated design. The only difference between the two is that the AmazonBasics design isn’t as biodegradable as Earth Rated, but users to have a choice to pick which type of bag they would prefer.Read more
You will have the option to select from a number of packages- and they all come with the addition of the leash clip dispenser. Options start at 270 units and run all the way up to 900 units- all while maintaining an affordable price tag and including a dispenser.
The basic design of the pouch is solid black without any prints on the front. It is an incredibly heavy duty pouch that measures to be 9 inches wide and 13 inches long- perfect for tying a secure knot when it has been used. The dispenser that is included is solid black and has an oblong oval shape. It can clip onto your pet’s leash so that you will never find yourself out for a walk without them.
There are 2 pouch designs that users can select from. The basic black pouch does not have any environmental benefits. However, the green pouch is made from EPI additives, which are also known as Totally Degradable Plastics. If you want to ensure that you get something that is good for the environment, opt for the green design.
If you were looking for something that came in large quantities and that wouldn’t break the bank- this is going to be your best bet. It doesn’t have a lot of the charm and flash that some of the other companies have- but it’s affordable.
While the black pouches aren’t as environmentally friendly as some of the others- they are tough, really thick, and incredibly affordable. If you were in the market for something that has an easy design and is durable- this is going to be your best bet.
Larger pouches make it easier to tie a secure knot
Made from EPI plastics
Slightly more expensive
Some find it too hard to open the individual pouches
Pogi’s makes pouches that not only have a fresh scent but are also come in a convenient packaging that makes it easy to store in the cupboard in your mudroom. They are made from high-quality materials that are safe for the environment and have a cute design on the exterior of the pouch.Read more
These are offered in a package of 10 rolls or 30 rolls. The package with 10 rolls as 150 pouches and the 30 roll model has 450 pouches. Unlike some of the other brands, this product doesn’t come with the addition of a dispenser.
The design of these green pouches has Pogi's mascot printed on the front. What is really unique about this brand is that the box that it comes in will slide right into your cupboard and dispense rolls as needed. These are also quite a bit bigger than the standard model out there on the market, and measures in at 13.5 inches long and 9.5 inches wide.
The materials used to make these pouches are made from EPI plastics, which means that over the span of 12-24 months when it is exposed to UV rays and oxygen. Also, all of the packaging that it comes in is made from 100 percent recycled materials.
As it comes with many of the heavily scented products- this product is set at just a slightly higher price point that some of the others out there on the market. However, if you need something that is a little bit bigger and will keep foul odors in check- this is well worth the slightly higher price point.
For those that need something with a fresh scent, and have bigger pets that require slightly bigger pouches- this is a great option that will fit perfectly in your cupboard.
7. My AlphaPet
Made from 100 percent recycled materials
Users find them easy to open, even in the winter
Sticker on roll always rips the first pouch
Pouches that are made from EPI plastics aren’t classified as biodegradable- however, this product is made from organic materials that make it considered biodegradable and compostable. This fact makes it unique to any of the other options out there on the market.Read more
Users have the option to select packages that come with 140 pouches or 240 pouches. Each roll contains 15 pouches, and it also doesn’t come with a dispenser with purchase.
The exterior of these pouches look a lot different than many of the other designs on the market. It only comes in a bright pink color with a playful pet design on the front, as well as text that restates that it is made from cornstarch. They come in the standard size of 9 inches wide and 13 inches long that make them easy to tie into a secure knot.
You aren’t going to get any more environmentally friendly than this product. It is made from cornstarch PBAT. The plant-based materials mean that when it is exposed to carbon dioxide and is even safe enough to throw into a compost bin. As it decomposes, it doesn’t release any harmful chemicals into the air or the soil. If you are someone that is concerned about the environment- these will be the perfect addition to your daily walks with your furry friend.
These are going to cost you just a little bit more than most of the other similar designs out there on the market. However, considering how good it is for the planet and easily it decomposes safely, it is well worth the added cost to know that you are helping the planet and not adding to the problem.
For those that want something that is made from 100 percent plant-based materials that are harmless for the environment, but is also big and durable enough to pick up waste up off of the ground without leaks or messes, My AlphaPet is a perfect addition to your daily walks.
Made from 100 percent biodegradable materials
You don’t need to carry a used pouch with you if you are walking along a wooded trail
Difficult to separate pouches
Smaller than the standard side
bioDOGradable is another option for pet owners that want something that is completely biodegradable. While it is made from natural materials that break down easily and safe enough to compost- they are a little bit smaller, harder to use, and more expensive than many of the other design out there on the market.Read more
Users can select options that come with 90 pouches, and go all the way up to 240 pouches. They are a little bit smaller than many of the other on the market, so making a secure knot may prove to be a little more difficult.
This pouch comes in an earth green that has the bioDOGradable logo on the front as well as all of the details of the materials used to make up the pouch.
bioDOGradable makes one of the best products on the market when it comes to the environment. They use all natural materials that can be thrown into a compost bin and they will break down in the span of a few months without letting off any toxic fumes into the air or into the soil.
The downside when it comes to this product has to do with the price. While it is really great for the planet, it isn’t very kind on your wallet. One package of 240 pouches will likely set you back the same amount you would spend on four 40 pound containers of kitty litter.
If you are willing to pay the additional cost for a smaller product that is good for the planet- this will be a great addition to take along with you on your daily walks around your neighborhood. The plus side is that you can even throw it into the woods after it has been used without it being considered littering.
Made from all natural materials
Affordable compostable option
Many feel they do not mask the smell
Users found the material was thin and began to break down while in use
Unni provides active pet owners pouches that are able to be thrown into a compost pile after they are used and they will be to break down in under 12 months without releasing any chemicals into the dirt or air. It should be noted that this product doesn’t have the same ability to mask odors the same way many of the others can.Read more
You can pick between two different boxes. One offers users 8 rolls that have 120 pouches, and the other has 18 rolls with 270 pouches.
These pouches are offered in the standard earthy green color with the branding of compost in big block letters along the front. This means that you can throw it off into the woods without other walkers thinking that you were littering. They come in the standard size of 9 inches wide and 13 inches long, so making a secure knot shouldn’t be a problem.
This is where this product really shines. It is made from completely biodegradable materials that are perfect for throwing into a compost bin and knowing that you are contaminating the soil or the air. This feature for the Unni design does come at a disadvantage. Many users find that this bag does not mask the smell and feels like it begins to break down even before you are finished using it.
The cost of this product is slightly more expensive than the other products that are made from EPI plastics, but it is not as expensive as many of the other compostable options out there on the market.
If you want to use an all natural pouch that is able to be composted, but you don’t want to spend the higher price point as some of the other similar designs out there on the market- this is an excellent option for you and your furry friends.
10. Mighty Paw
Safe for landfills
For those that want something incredibly heavy duty- these will be perfect for their walks with their pets. They aren’t compostable like some options on the market, but they are made from materials that are considered to be environmentally friendly. Their quality design makes them priced a little bit higher than some of the other options on the market, but many users feel like they are worth the slightly padded price tag.Read more
Users can select from a box that has 8 rolls or 40 rolls. The 8 roll box has 120 pouches, and the 40 roll box has 600 pouches.
Users can select on pouches that come in classic green or orange, and each one has a cute Mighty Paw mascot printed on the front. They are a lot thicker than many similar designs on the market, and they measure to be 9 inches wide and 13 inches long- which is the standard size for these products.
While you cannot throw them into a compost bin, the materials used will eventually break down over time, and without releasing any toxic chemicals into the air or soil. There are words printed on the front to ensure users that they are safe for landfills.
The cost seems to be a bit of an issue for users. While they are incredibly safe to use and durable, the price is quite higher than some of the other designs on the market, and users are conflicted as to whether the higher price is worth it.
If you are looking for something that is incredibly thick that also has a fresh scent to mask foul odors- this is an excellent choice if you are willing to pay a slightly higher price tag.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
We focused on a couple of different things in this section. First, we took a look at how many bags are included with each order.
Secondly, we were drawn to products that offered up just a little bit more than receptacles. Many brands on the market offered up dispensers to keep your rolls as you walk. These are great because it means that you don’t have to carry around a loose pouch with you as you walk, and it also means that you will never be caught without another bag if nature happens to call twice for old Rover out on your walk. These dispensers typically fit right on to the leash and can hold up to 20 pouches at one time. Some brands even have a hook on the back so that you can hang a used pouch off of it so you don’t have to carry it all the way back to the trash can.
Naturally, we were drawn to anything that had a fun and clever design on the outside. Sure, you could just carry plain black plastic, but why would you want to when there are so many fun and adorable options out there on the market? We loved products that had cute and clever designs on the outside, such as paw prints or pictures of funny animals. Perhaps it’s psychological, but we feel like fun and colorful options makes the unpleasant task of picking up after your furry friends a little less icky.
Any time that you use anything disposable that is made from plastic, you might wonder how harmful it is to the environment. While you want to do your part to ensure that you keep your sidewalks and parks clean, you also don’t want to add any unnecessary plastics to the already troubled landfills and oceans. We made sure to inspect the materials that were used for these products to ensure that they didn’t release any harmful chemicals into the air or into the soil. What we found is that there are two types of materials that are used to make these products. One is considered to be eco-friendly (but isn’t considered to be biodegradable) and the other is compostable and is, in fact, biodegradable. Products made from EPI plastics will break down over time if they are exposed to UV rays (sunlight) and oxygen. They won’t break down completely, but over the span of 12-24 months the plastics will begin to break apart, and they won’t release any harmful chemicals. Products made from compostable materials typically use vegetable byproducts such as cornstarch. These are ideal for the environment because they can be thrown onto a compost pile and will break down in about 6 months. While they are better for the environment, they typically don’t have the same sturdy structure of a pouch made from EPI plastic.
Yes, the value of an item always crosses our mind when shopping. Put simply, to determine the value of the dog bags, you could do the math and see how much each bag costs. However, this is a common mistake. To determine the value, you must also consider the materials used and, features, and durability. If the bags are low quality (none featured on our list!), you'll end up using two each time. We also found the products that include a dispenser to be slightly more valuable.
Expert Interviews & Opinions
A lot of pet owners not only use this while taking their pooches for a walk, but they also use it for their cats. Cleaning a litter box should be a daily chore- according to a vast majority of pet owners. Cats are clean creatures, and if a litter box isn’t being cleaned to their impossible standards- they might use the throw blanket at the end of your bed as their new box as they wait for you to clean theirs. Using plastic grocery bags might work in a pinch, but using smaller bags specifically designed for pet waste might be the best way to go. Plus, they are more eco-friendly than grocery bags, and many of them can be tossed right into the compost bin.
The difference should be pretty clear- one is used for animal waste and the other is used for carrying food home from the market. The kind you bring home from the market isn’t made from safe materials such as plant-based products or EPI plastics that are safe for the air and the soil. Plus, when you tie them up they still emit a foul odor. These products sometimes are scented to mask the odor of its contents, and they can sit in an outdoor trash can for a few days without smelling.
Other Factors to Consider
When you think about it- the only thing that stands between your hand and a fresh pile of eaten and digested and dispensed kibble is a thin layer of plastic. With this idea in mind, we wanted to make sure that the products we selected were made with durable materials that wouldn’t rip or tear when used. Products that used EPI plastics were the most durable plastics and were also pretty thick, but they were also considered to be good for the environment. When you get into vegetable based products that are able to be composted- that’s when the durability begins to decline. Before you make a purchase, determine what type of material you will feel more comfortable using.
Frequently Asked Questions
q: What do I do with the pouch after I use it?
Typically, most users simply toss it into the garbage can at the park or when they get back home. The bag is able to contain the smell, so even if you throw it away 5 days from trash pick up, it shouldn’t smell up your garbage can. If you feel strange about sending your dog’s waste to the landfill, there is another thing that pet owners do that you might find a little strange. Some owners, upon returning home, dump the contents of the bag in the toilet and flush it away, and they throw the bag into the garbage. This method keeps actual waste out of the landfills, and into the sewers with all of the other actual waste.
q: What should I do if my pet ate one?
It might seem like a strange question, but you would be surprised how many times this happens. Our pets are great and lovable, but they can sure make some questionable decisions sometimes. Some of them just cannot resist the siren call of a plastic pouch filled with used kibble. So, what should you do if Fido decided to reclaimed his used kibble and eat the entire bag? Typically, these pouches are small enough that it shouldn’t be cause for alarm bells. Many pet owners that have experienced his strange occurrence have found that the animal will typically pass it in a day or two- you just need to make sure that you keep an eye on him or her. If you notice any strange behavior, or if they never pass it, it might be time to pay your local veterinarian a visit.
q: Why can’t I just leave the waste at the side of the trail?
Let’s say you are going on a hike on a trail that isn’t very traveled, and your dog decides to leave a present on the side of the trail in the woody area. You might want to leave it there and claim that no one will step in it, and it will fertilize the soil- but you would be horribly wrong. Dog waste has a lot of nitrogen and phosphorus in it due to their diets that are high in protein, so it’s presence in the soil can have an adverse reaction than of say, cow manure (cow manure is safe because they only eat plants). Not only is it bad for the soil, but you will also run the risk of someone catching you not picking up after your pet, and suddenly you gain the reputation of the person that doesn’t pick up after your pet. Don’t be that person.
q: Are there any downsides?
As with any product, there are a few downsides. If you are a pet owner that has trouble bending over to pick something up, you might have a little bit of a problem with this product. If you can’t bend down to pick it up, you might be better off with a classic pooper scooper. These products have long handles so that you can scoop up animal waste without the need to bend over. The downside to these products, however, is that you will be carrying it back with you and there is no way to mask the odor like you can with a bag. However, you could always bring both along. Use the scooper to pick it up, and then place it into the pouch and tie it up.
q: Are they really biodegradable?
You have to be careful when shopping for these products because some are labeled as eco-friendly and some are labeled as biodegradable. It is important to point out that these two terms are not referencing the same thing. Eco-friendly simple means that they are not made from materials that are toxic to the air or soil. Eco-friendly is typically referencing a material called EPI plastic. This type of plastic will slowly start to break down in 12-24 months. Unlike most plastics, when this material begins to break down it will not release any harmful chemicals into the air or into the soil. Compostable options are the true biodegradable options. These typically are made from natural plant-based materials that will decompose in about 6 months and will not release any harmful chemicals into the air or soil.